What to Do if Your Insurance Company is Stalling in Minnesota: A Comprehensive Guide

---

Insurance Company Stalling? A Minnesota Homeowner's Guide to Action

The storm that rolled through Lake Elmo is a memory, but the evidence of its fury remains. The blue tarp on your roof is a constant reminder of the damage, and a growing stack of bills is a testament to the cost. You filed your insurance claim, expecting a partner in your recovery. Instead, you got something far more frustrating: silence.

Weeks turn into a month. Your calls go to voicemail. Your emails get vague, automated replies. The adjuster you spoke to once is now "no longer on your case." You're stuck in insurance limbo, and it feels like you're powerless.

Let’s be perfectly clear: This is often a deliberate strategy.

Feeling ignored by your insurance company is one of the most maddening experiences a policyholder can face. But you are not powerless. This guide will pull back the curtain on why insurers stall, help you distinguish a legitimate delay from illegal bad faith tactics, and give you a step-by-step Minnesota action plan to fight back and get the money you are owed.

Inside the Insurer's Playbook: Why They Intentionally Stall Your Claim

Understanding why your insurer is delaying your claim is the first step to countering their strategy. It’s rarely about simple disorganization; it’s about money.

1. The "War of Attrition"

This is a psychological game. The insurer knows you're under immense financial and emotional pressure. Your house needs repairs, you might be displaced, and the bills are piling up. The longer they make you wait, the more desperate you become. The goal is to wear you down until you’re so exhausted and frustrated that you’ll jump at the first lowball settlement they offer, just to make the nightmare end. They are counting on your fatigue.

2. Playing the "Float" 💰

Insurance companies make a significant portion of their profits not just from collecting premiums, but from investing that money (known as "the float"). Every day they hold onto the money that rightfully belongs to you is another day that money is sitting in their investment accounts, earning interest for them. For a single claim, it’s a small amount. Multiplied across thousands of claims, delaying payouts by 30, 60, or 90 days translates into millions in investment income for them.

3. Weaponizing the Statute of Limitations

In Minnesota, there is a legal time limit for you to file a lawsuit against your insurance company over a property damage claim (typically two years from the date of loss, but this can vary). An insurer might use stalling tactics—endless requests for information, reassigning adjusters—to drag the process out, hoping you'll miss this critical deadline. If the statute of limitations expires, your legal right to sue them vanishes, and they are off the hook completely.

Legitimate Delay or Illegal Bad Faith? Know the Difference

Not every delay is illegal. Sometimes, there are valid reasons for a claim to take time. The key is recognizing when a reasonable wait crosses the line into bad faith—a legal term for when an insurer fails to uphold their contractual duty to you.

Signs of a Potentially LEGITIMATE Delay:

• High Claim Volume: After a major hailstorm or derecho hits a large area, even the best insurers get backlogged. Communication might be slow, but it should still be consistent.

• Complex Investigation: If there are questions about the cause of the loss (e.g., potential arson in a fire claim), a deeper, more time-consuming investigation is reasonable.

• Waiting on Your Documentation: If you haven't provided the necessary photos, receipts, or contractor estimates, the insurer can't move forward.

RED FLAGS of a Potential BAD FAITH Delay 🚩:

• The Ghosting: Failing to return your calls or emails for weeks at a time (generally, more than 30 days without a substantive update is a major red flag).

• The Document Treadmill: Repeatedly asking for documents or information you have already sent. This is a classic stalling tactic.

• The Adjuster Carousel: Your claim is reassigned to a new adjuster every few weeks, and each new person claims to be "just getting up to speed."

• Refusing to Provide a Reason: They won't give you a straight answer in writing explaining why the claim is delayed.

• Misrepresenting Your Policy: They tell you something isn't covered when a plain reading of your policy shows that it is.

• Delaying Without Investigating: They delay payment for months without conducting any meaningful investigation, like inspecting the property or interviewing witnesses.

If you are seeing more red flags than legitimate reasons, it's time to stop waiting and start acting.

Your Step-by-Step Minnesota Action Plan to Fight Back

Follow these phases in order. This plan is designed to build pressure methodically and create a paper trail that will be invaluable later.

Phase 1: The Paper Trail Imperative (Start Immediately)

From this moment on, you are building a case. Documentation is your most powerful weapon.

• Create a Communication Log: Use a simple notebook or a spreadsheet. For every single interaction (phone call, email, letter), log the following:

  • Date and Time

  • Name and Title of the person you spoke with

  • A Summary of the conversation (what they said, what you said)

  • Any Follow-up Actions promised

• Communicate in Writing: After every phone call, send a polite follow-up email confirming what was discussed. This creates a written record of their verbal statements.

  • Sample Email Snippet: "Hi [Adjuster's Name], just wanted to follow up on our phone call today, [Date] at [Time]. Per our conversation, you stated you would [action they promised]. I look forward to receiving that by [date]. Please let me know if my understanding is incorrect. Thank you."

• Send Everything via Certified Mail: For any formal requests or important documents, spend the extra few dollars for certified mail with a return receipt. This proves they received it and when.

Phase 2: Escalation Inside the Company (After 30 Days of Stalling)

If your adjuster is ghosting you, it's time to go over their head.

1. Ask for a Supervisor: Call the general claims number and politely but firmly state, "My adjuster, [Name], has not responded to my inquiries for [number] days. I need to be connected with their direct supervisor immediately."

2. Use Key Phrases: When you speak to the supervisor, be calm and professional. Explain the timeline of your claim and the lack of communication. Then, use this powerful phrase: "I am concerned that this unreasonable delay may violate Minnesota's Unfair Claims Practices Act." This shows them you know your rights and that you are taking this seriously.

3. Demand a Response in Writing: End the call by stating that you require a written update on the status of your claim and a clear timeline for a decision within 5-7 business days. Follow up with an email documenting this request.

Phase 3: Bringing in Outside Help (When Internal Escalation Fails)

If the supervisor doesn't resolve the issue, it’s time to bring in outside forces.

1. File a Complaint with the State: The Minnesota Department of Commerce oversees the insurance industry. Filing a complaint is free and can be done online. This is a huge step. When the state gets involved, insurance companies are legally required to respond. This often breaks the logjam immediately.

   • You can find the complaint form here: Minnesota Department of Commerce - File a Complaint

2. Hire a Public Adjuster: This is the game-changer. A public adjuster is a licensed professional who works for you, not the insurance company. The moment you hire a public adjuster, the power dynamic shifts.

   • They take over all communication. No more stressful phone calls for you.

   • They conduct their own expert damage assessment.

   • They know the insurer's playbook and how to counter every stalling tactic.

   • A formal "Letter of Representation" from a public adjuster tells the insurance company that the games are over and a professional is now managing the claim.

How Shoreline Public Adjusters Breaks a Stalled Claim

When a client comes to us with a stalled claim, we launch an immediate, aggressive strategy. We don't just ask for updates; we challenge the delay itself. We re-document the entire loss with overwhelming detail and submit a comprehensive package that is difficult for the insurer to dispute or ignore.

We leverage provisions in your policy, like the Appraisal Clause, which can force a resolution when there are disputes over the amount of loss. We take the entire burden off your shoulders, ending the stress and forcing the accountability your insurer has been avoiding.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: What is legally considered an "unreasonable delay" in Minnesota? A: While there isn't a magic number of days, Minnesota statutes require insurers to acknowledge and act upon claims with "reasonable promptness." Generally, if you have not received a decision or a very good reason for a delay within 30-60 days of providing all requested information, it's likely moving into "unreasonable" territory.

Q: Can I sue my insurance company for bad faith in Minnesota? A: Yes. If you can prove that your insurer intentionally and unreasonably delayed or denied your claim without proper cause, you may have grounds for a bad faith lawsuit. This is a separate legal action that can allow you to recover more than just your policy benefits, but it requires consultation with an attorney.

Q: Does filing a complaint with the Department of Commerce cost me anything? A: No. It is a free public service designed to protect consumers like you.

You Have the Right to Get Paid. We Can Help You Enforce It.

Stalling is a strategy of powerlessness. The insurance company wants you to feel isolated, exhausted, and desperate. But you are not. You have rights, and there are powerful steps you can take to enforce them.

By documenting everything, escalating professionally, and knowing when to bring in an expert advocate, you can take back control of your claim.

If you are stuck in insurance limbo, don't wait another day. Contact Shoreline Public Adjusters for a free, no-obligation consultation. Let us take over the fight.

Shoreline Public Adjusters, LLC
780 Fifth Avenue South
Suite #200
Naples, FL 34102

Email: hello@teamshoreline.com
Phone: 954-546-1899
Fax: 239-778-9889